Why has the US economy remained so strong?

Keep knowledgeable with free updates

Merely signal as much as the US economic system myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.

If 18 months of rising rates of interest from the Federal Reserve had been supposed to place a chill on the world’s largest economic system, US customers had one other thought.

New federal information on Thursday confirmed the US economic system expanded by an annualised fee of 4.9 per cent within the third quarter — a blistering tempo that, not for the primary time, defied gloomier predictions from economists.

“It has been an train in humility,” stated Kathy Bostjancic, chief economist at Nationwide, referring to forecasters’ dim report for the reason that pandemic.

What made Thursday’s explosive gross home product quantity — the strongest since 2021 — so stunning was what preceded it: essentially the most aggressive marketing campaign by the Fed to tighten financial coverage in many years. The central financial institution has raised rates of interest 11 occasions since March final 12 months, to a 22-year excessive of 5.25 per cent to five.5 per cent — all in an try to chill the economic system and quell inflation.

Inflation has fallen. However the economic system remained removed from subdued this summer time.

Nonetheless, as off the mark as they’ve been over latest months, economists warn US GDP is unlikely to maintain defying gravity for for much longer.

The beautiful resilience within the US economic system to this point has stemmed from one major power: client spending, which was by far the largest contributor to the economic system’s growth within the third quarter, accounting for greater than half of the annualised enhance. Buoyed by a wholesome labour market, persevering with demand for employees gave folks confidence to maintain shopping for. 

“It has been unbelievable job development actually propelling client spending,” Bostjancic stated.

Furthermore, what had “turbocharged” this dynamic was a sense amongst customers that they had been flush with money.

“Steadiness sheets look in actually good condition, shares have usually carried out rather well, housing costs are very excessive, and even should you don’t have property, you will have this pool of pandemic-related financial savings,” she added.

However, like different economists and policymakers, Bostjancic expects this momentum to fade, particularly because the Fed’s previous rate of interest will increase chew, and corporations and households wrestle below the burden of the surging borrowing prices after authorities bond yields hit multiyear highs.

Indicators that client energy is waning are seen. Of greater than $2tn in extra financial savings stockpiled for the reason that pandemic, for instance, economists estimate that the majority has been drawn down. Furthermore, reckons Nancy Vanden Houten at Oxford Economics, what stays is concentrated amongst wealthier households. Companies are additionally turning extra cautious.

Gregory Daco, chief economist at EY-Parthenon, stated he thinks the US financial engine that carried out so strongly within the third quarter is about to sputter.

He stated: “The entire optimistic drivers of client spending had been revving fairly strongly over the course of the summer time, however we’ve seen a few of these drivers reasonable fairly considerably and anticipate [others to moderate] over the course of the approaching months.”

Daco added: “If companies begin to really feel the strain of getting increased debt servicing prices and low utilisation on the labour entrance, and in the event that they begin to really feel the necessity to reduce prices as a result of they received’t essentially be capable of attain the revenues that they focused, then that begins to create extra of a snowball impact.”

Hints of “price fatigue” had been evident within the newest GDP information, Daco stated, with non-residential mounted funding — which tracks companies’ spending on equipment and different gear — falling 0.1 per cent on a quarter-over-quarter foundation. That was the third decline on this class within the final 4 quarters — an indication, stated economists at Morgan Stanley, that “increased charges are weighing on enterprise exercise”.

In keeping with forecasts compiled by Bloomberg, most economists now anticipate US GDP development to fall to 0.8 per cent subsequent quarter — greater than 4 share factors beneath the third-quarter quantity — earlier than bottoming out at 0.2 per cent within the first three months of 2024. Ian Shepherdson at Pantheon Economics reckons development may even drop to zero subsequent quarter, though he acknowledged there’s a huge margin of error.

Whether or not the US economic system finally suggestions right into a recession, nevertheless, is a much more contested problem.

Janet Yellen, the Treasury secretary, on Thursday stated the information doesn’t recommend “any signal of recession”, whilst she acknowledged that final quarter’s tempo of development is unlikely to be repeated. Fed chair Jay Powell has additionally maintained there’s nonetheless a path for a comfortable touchdown.

Daco sees the chances of a recession subsequent 12 months as even. However he was cautious in regards to the forecasts. “We’ve discovered to be very humble in our capacity to foretell,” he stated.

Extra reporting by Eva Xiao and Oliver Roeder