Inside the White House Program to Share America’s Secrets

On the afternoon of Sept. 27, a Balkans knowledgeable on the White Home acquired a disturbing name from a U.S. intelligence company. Serbian forces had been massing alongside the size of their nation’s border with Kosovo, the place NATO has stored an uneasy peace since a bloody war of secession in 1999. Three days earlier, greater than two dozen armed Serbs had killed a Kosovar police officer in an assault. Now Serbia was deploying heavy weapons and troops. “We had been very anxious that Serbia could possibly be getting ready to launch a army invasion,” says one Nationwide Safety Council (NSC) official.

The query was what to do about it. Months of mounting tensions in a distant nook of southeastern Europe had not acquired a lot consideration within the media. Diplomatic efforts by the U.Ok., Italy, and different international locations with troops on the bottom in Kosovo had did not calm the state of affairs. In Washington, consideration was centered on chaos in Congress; in a lot of Europe, the highest precedence was marshaling continued support for Ukraine. In order a part of an effort to stress Serbia to again down, U.S. Nationwide Safety Adviser Jake Sullivan authorised a request from his Europe staff to declassify components of the Serbian buildup for public launch.

The NSC Intelligence Directorate edited the key particulars of the buildup to obscure the sources and strategies behind the intelligence. Then it shipped the request to the workplace of the Director of Nationwide Intelligence (ODNI) in Northern Virginia by way of categorized e-mail. On Sept. 29, after a two-day scramble to clear the declassification, NSC spokesperson John Kirby convened an unscheduled Zoom name with members of the White Home press corps. Kirby gave new details about the Sept. 24 assault on the Kosovar police officer and broke the information of the most recent Serbian deployment, revealing that it included superior artillery, tanks, and mechanized infantry items. As protection spiked, European international locations joined the U.S. in making use of new diplomatic stress on the Serbs, and the U.Ok. introduced a further troop deployment to Kosovo. Inside days, Serbian troops had been pulling again.

The declassification and launch of the Serbian troop actions is one instance of a novel White Home method to utilizing intelligence that has grown out of the U.S. response to the war in Ukraine. Beginning within the fall of 2021, as U.S. spies turned satisfied Russia was getting ready to invade, Sullivan labored with Director of Nationwide Intelligence Avril Haines and CIA Director William Burns to “downgrade” categorized particulars of Moscow’s strikes. “We had been sitting on this troubling data,” says Maher Bitar, NSC coordinator for intelligence and protection coverage, “and we wanted to get forward of what the Russians had been going to do.”

Greater than two years later, the White Home has constructed a broad program to share secrets and techniques when it serves strategic objectives. About as soon as every week, White Home officers see intelligence that they need to make public and get approval from Sullivan to strive, greater than a dozen present and former White Home and national-security officers inform TIME. Intelligence officers on the NSC ship requests to the ODNI, which processes them, agreeing on cleared language with those that created the secrets and techniques to start with. “The final word choice on whether or not to green-light or red-light a given piece of knowledge rests with the professionals within the intelligence group,” Sullivan says.

Learn Extra: China’s Ambitions, Russia’s Nukes and TikTok: Spy Chiefs Talk Biggest U.S. Security Threats

The motivation behind this system, the officers say, is that it really works. Strategic declassification has denied Russian President Vladimir Putin “false narratives,” Burns stated in a speech final summer season, “placing him within the uncomfortable and unaccustomed place of being on his again foot.” The hassle has expanded past Russia. The U.S. has declassified intelligence to blunt Chinese language saber-rattling within the Taiwan Strait, to stress Iran to cease supplying weapons to the Houthis attacking delivery vessels within the Purple Sea, and to counter Hamas’ false claims about Israeli strikes. “It is a sport changer,” says Kirby. “I hope they by no means put it again within the bottle.”

The U.S. has selectively declassified and leaked intelligence for so long as it has collected it, however the Biden Administration’s secret-sharing program is new in a number of methods, present and former intelligence officers say. The place as soon as the ODNI acquired one or two downgrade requests a month, it now typically receives many greater than that in a day. Whereas different companies have jumped into the declassification sport, a lot of the work is pushed out of the White Home. Reasonably than leaking one-off intelligence scoops, NSC officers mix a number of secrets and techniques with open-source intelligence from commercial-satellite imagery, battlefield bloggers, and information stories, distributing packages that echo the completed intelligence stories they obtain each morning. “It’s been performed piecemeal over time,” says former CIA spokesman Invoice Harlow. “It’s extra strategic and orchestrated this time.”

Not everybody thinks that’s an excellent factor. Skeptics level to the U.S. authorities’s historical past of cherry-picking intelligence to deceive foreigners, and People, in the course of the Chilly Battle and to justify the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Members of the U.S. intel group, ever protecting of their secrets and techniques, need to restrict this system to the battle in Ukraine. Some in each events fear a White Home–run propaganda effort could possibly be used for private or political benefit. “Now we’ve acquired this declassification weapon that, put within the flawed palms, may be very harmful,” says a former CIA official.

Learn Extra: As Russia’s Full-Scale Invasion Enters Its Third Year, Optimism for Ukraine Sinks

However the world of secrets and techniques is altering, and America is scrambling to adapt. Russia has refined its social media propaganda operation so aggressively since 2016 that it believes only one% of its bot military is detected on platforms like X and TikTok, in accordance with a U.S. intelligence doc printed final 12 months by the Washington Submit. China is utilizing superior AI in its propaganda operations, the Rand Corp. stated in a latest report. Sharing America’s secrets and techniques with the world earlier than enemies attempt to affect and undermine democracies, advocates say, is likely one of the finest methods to combat again. “We’ve realized you may beat a mislead the punch if you already know it’s coming,” says Kirby. “We’re getting out forward of them.”

On the similar time, the proliferation of categorized data implies that America’s secrets and techniques are value lower than they was—and are tougher to maintain. The U.S. intelligence group sucks up the equal of 29 petabytes or 500 billion pages value of knowledge every single day, classifies tens of hundreds of thousands of paperwork a 12 months, and produces an estimated 50,000 categorized stories yearly, in accordance with the Nationwide Safety Company, the Nationwide Archives, and public reporting. Accused mass leakers Edward Snowden and Airman First Class Jack Teixeira had been each IT employees employed to handle that ocean of intel. Presidents Joe Biden and Donald Trump have confronted special-counsel investigations for his or her sloppy handling of classified data. America’s try to soundly warehouse billions of secrets and techniques is failing from the highest of the intel chain to the underside. As Justice Potter Stewart stated within the Pentagon Papers case, “When every little thing is assessed, then nothing is assessed, and the system turns into one to be disregarded by the cynical or the careless, and to be manipulated by these intent on self-protection or self-promotion.”

The result’s a poisonous mixture of public skepticism and diminished safety. The share of People who imagine the intelligence group respects their privateness and civil liberties dropped from 52% in 2020 to 44% in 2022, in accordance with a College of Texas survey. After revelations of abuse by the FBI, Congress is struggling to resume the controversial Part 702 mass-surveillance program that the federal government says is essential to combating every little thing from fentanyl trafficking to terrorism to Chinese language spies.

Learn Extra: How the Surveillance of Immigrants Remade American Policing

In its declassification program, the White Home thinks it has the beginning of a solution to all three issues: disinformation, overclassification, and public mistrust. “That’s a reasonably good 1, 2, 3 from my perspective,” Sullivan tells TIME. He provides, “Clearly, this method should evolve over time as we study extra.” The story of how the Biden Administration developed its secret-sharing program, and the seek for use it safely, reveals how far the U.S. authorities nonetheless has to go.

The primary goal of the American secret sharers’ efforts was Vladimir Putin. In mid
-October 2021, senior national-security leaders briefed the President, Sullivan, and different White Home officers that Russia was getting ready to invade Ukraine. Sullivan’s first response was shock. The second was to provide you with a strategy to deter it. Biden determined to ship Burns, a seasoned diplomat and former ambassador to Russia, to confront Putin. “We wished to show to the Russians that we had been conscious of their planning to launch an invasion of Ukraine with the intention to disabuse them of the concept that they might have the ingredient of shock,” says Eric Inexperienced, then the senior director for Russia and Central Asia on the NSC. “However we additionally wished to verify what Bill Burns stated was not burning sources and strategies.” The consequence was a “downgrade,” or partial declassification, of the briefing Sullivan and the senior U.S. officers had acquired, Inexperienced remembers.

Burns ended up confronting Putin remotely in early November, reaching him by telephone within the resort city of Sochi from the Moscow workplace of the Russian President’s international coverage adviser. The U.S. spy chief left Russia feeling he had made no progress. The subsequent step was to attempt to unite America’s allies behind the hassle to discourage an invasion. On the best way again from Russia, the U.S. staff briefed E.U. and NATO companions with a extra detailed presentation of the intelligence. The Europeans had been skeptical. “The French and the Germans and others had been like, ‘You guys at all times overreact to those issues. Russia’s acquired an excessive amount of to lose,’” says a senior U.S. intelligence official. After listening to the European doubts, Haines recalled in a 2023 interview with Politico, Biden stated, “OK, it is advisable to get on the market. We have to begin sharing intelligence.”

Learn Extra: How Tech Giants Turned Ukraine Into an AI War Lab

On the head of the hassle had been Sullivan and his deputy on the NSC, Jon Finer. Former journalists, they admire greater than some the worth of being first. “There was a way that by doing it pro-actively we’d have extra affect over the narrative,” says Inexperienced, who additionally noticed an ethical element to the choice: “This was such a monumental chance that we had an obligation to tell the general public.” And, Inexperienced provides, “If we stored it beneath wraps, after which it got here out that we knew, that may be an untenable state of affairs.”

The group determined to declassify proof that Russian troops had been massing close to Ukraine’s borders. They discovered commercial-satellite images that confirmed the identical troop buildups they’d seen on the U.S. spy platforms. They mixed these photos with a few of the particulars from the briefing that had stunned them, in addition to with information stories and different public data, and labored with the intelligence group to provide a declassified model. They then gave the package deal to Shane Harris, a veteran Washington Submit intelligence reporter. On Dec. 3, the Submit ran the story. Different information shops jumped to cowl the troop buildup. Although the Russians denied they had been getting ready for warfare, the general public dialog about the potential of an invasion shifted. By the NSC’s lights, the transfer was successful.

They determined to do extra. In January, U.S. intelligence noticed mounting preparations for a false-flag operation that Moscow meant to make use of as a justification for an invasion. Russia was getting ready to stage an assault in separatist jap Ukraine, full with movie of faux victims, the intelligence group reported. After issuing a basic warning, the NSC ready a extra detailed package deal and acquired it cleared for launch. On Feb. 3, then White Home press secretary Jen Psaki after which State Division spokesperson Ned Worth briefed reporters on the plot.

Not everybody was satisfied. “What proof do it’s important to help the concept that there’s some propaganda movie within the making?” requested Matt Lee, the State Division correspondent at AP. Worth, sticking to his speaking factors, repeated the allegation with out offering additional proof. The alternate went viral and highlighted the challenges to the method. Declassification would solely work, the NSC concluded, if it had sufficient credibility to beat the U.S. historical past of unhealthy intelligence and propaganda abuse.

Because it turned out, the Russians ran the false-flag play anyway. On Feb. 18, an explosion rocked the pro-Russia-separatist region of Donetsk, and native leaders there referred to as on Moscow to intervene militarily. However in opposition to the backdrop of the White Home briefings, the Russian pretext supplied no diplomatic cowl. By some accounts, the pre-bunking delayed the Russian invasion. “We all know it purchased at the least every week,” Kirby says.

Nevertheless it didn’t stop it. Russian tanks rolled throughout Ukraine’s borders in late February 2022, grabbing swaths of territory within the east of the nation and coming inside miles of the presidential palace in Kyiv. Again in Washington, the key sharers expanded their efforts.

The Workplace of the Director of Nationwide Intelligence is headquartered in a suburban advanced in northern Virginia generally known as Liberty Crossing. Two massive steel-and-glass buildings within the shapes of an L and an X are hidden up a drive behind an embankment, a stand of timber, and safety checkpoints. Since 2008, the advanced has housed the intelligence group’s umbrella group, created after 9/11 to handle the 18 typically competing, usually territorial, companies that gather and analyze America’s secrets and techniques.

Learn Extra: ‘Who Else Is Spying on Me?’ Muslim Americans Bring the Fight Against Surveillance to the Supreme Court

Within the two-story foyer of the L-shaped constructing, rows of safety turnstiles and low-ceilinged elevator banks lead as much as the workplace that handles data administration for the intelligence group. It’s not massive: fewer than 10 officers are assigned to the job. The declassification requests they fielded within the run-up to the Russian invasion began out as emails over the categorized community, primarily from Biden, Sullivan, and the White Home, and grew to incorporate petitions from different companies and departments. ODNI declined to say how most of the downgrade requests are for nonpublic or covert functions, and what number of are for full declassification and official public launch.

To assist take care of the spiking variety of requests, the NSC organized its course of. Proposed downgrades needed to meet sure strategic goals. Within the case of Ukraine, says Kirby, these had been to help Kyiv’s success on the battlefield, bolster NATO, and keep away from drawing the U.S. straight into the warfare. The requested intelligence needed to be based mostly on high-confidence assessments, not the low- or medium-ones that had proved false in Iraq. Sullivan approves these requests about two-thirds of the time, in accordance with Kirby and different White Home officers.

Not everybody was keen to assist. Intelligence officers who had categorized secrets and techniques to start with had been loath to declassify them, officers on all sides of the method say. However in Haines, Sullivan had an ally. A lawyer and physicist who as soon as owned an indie bookstore in Baltimore and had a pastime of rebuilding every little thing from TVs to twin-engine planes, she rose to be deputy head of the CIA in 2013. “Having a system that may facilitate such sharing,” she stated in January 2023, “and finally having the assets to assessment and downgrade, or declassify what might be launched, is crucial.”

Learn Extra: How a New Bipartisan Task Force Is Thinking About Artificial Intelligence

Over time, the ODNI created a system to hurry response and create information each of the request to declassify the intelligence and of its authorization. The template contains the date of the request, the deadline, who’s asking for the downgrade, who’s going to make use of it, what the cleared language can be, the place the intelligence got here from, and the justification for declassification. Normally such requests take weeks to course of. Now the velocity relies upon partly on how delicate the intelligence is, says one official concerned within the course of.

In some instances, approval went all the best way as much as Burns or the heads of different intelligence companies. The most important concern was defending sources and strategies. The White House realized to not ask for the declassification of full, completed stories, as a substitute focusing on particular person information, or maps and graphics. “Strategic downgrades needed to imply strategic, it simply couldn’t be each tactical piece of intelligence we got here throughout,” says Sullivan. Over time, these concerned say, program runners within the intelligence group noticed how their sanitized data was used publicly, and acquired in.

That meant increasingly more declassification. From March 2022 on, the U.S. launched intelligence about potential Chinese language help for Russia, Russian assaults in opposition to Ukrainian storage services, Russia’s naval blockade within the Black Sea, and Iranian and North Korean help for the warfare. The secrets and techniques had been mixed with publicly obtainable data, in accordance with senior White Home officers, together with naval maritime information, commercial-satellite imagery, and social media exercise.

Alongside the best way, the NSC staff started increasing using declassified materials. Forward of then Home Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s go to to Taiwan in August 2022, Kirby briefed a declassified intelligence-community evaluation of the steps China may absorb response, together with army provocations like firing missiles within the Taiwan Strait. The aim was to decrease the shock worth of any retaliation by Beijing for Pelosi’s journey, a senior White Home official says.

The U.S. has additionally used declassification within the Israel-Hamas War. The White Home twice downgraded intelligence about what they stated was Hamas’ use of al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza as a army command heart “to assist clarify to folks how [Hamas fighters] have deeply embedded themselves throughout the civilian inhabitants,” says an NSC official aware of the choice. In late December, the White Home launched downgraded intelligence claiming Iran had transferred drones and cruise missiles to Houthi militants in Yemen that had been getting used to assault ships within the Purple Sea.

Learn Extra: Human Rights Watch Accuses Israel of Blocking Aid to Gaza

Even this system’s most enthusiastic backers admit the outcomes are blended. Finer, Sullivan’s deputy, instructed an intelligence convention in July that the U.S. had used it to efficiently deter Russian arms offers with China and Iran, and to construct help for war-crimes fees on the Hague. But months of downgrades meant to forestall arms transfers from North Korea to Russia failed, as have makes an attempt to stress Iran to chop off army help for the Houthis.

In late January 2023, Kirby acquired a letter by way of courier that was postmarked st. petersburg. Having grown up in St. Petersburg, Fla., he thought the letter might need one thing to do with the house he nonetheless owns there. However on nearer examination, he found it had come not from the southeastern U.S. however from northwestern Russia. Contained in the envelope was a typed observe. “Pricey Mr Kirby, Might you please make clear what crime was dedicated by PMC Wagner?” It was hand-signed: “Yevgeny Prigozhin.”

The second was one thing of a milestone within the U.S.-Russia propaganda battle: a direct alternate between adversaries within the data house. Prigozhin was the top of the Wagner Group, which ran a key mercenary pressure on the bottom in Ukraine. Simply days earlier than receiving Prigozhin’s letter, Kirby had introduced at a White Home press briefing that the U.S. was designating Wagner as a transnational prison group and imposing sanctions on the group.

Learn Extra: Inside the Little-Known U.S. Arms Control Center in Daily Contact With Russia

Earlier than main the mercenary group, one in all Prigozhin’s claims to fame was as a worldwide disinformation operator. In 2016, he organized the primary Russian troll farms that infiltrated U.S. social media in the course of the presidential election, a part of a marketing campaign that pushed propaganda to 126 million folks on Fb, in accordance with the corporate. The Justice Division indicted Prigozhin for his function within the scheme. Prigozhin’s personalised response to Wagner’s prison designation bolstered the White Home’s sense that declassification had given the U.S. a brand new weapon within the working battle in opposition to Russia’s propagandists. “It confirmed we had been getting inside his head,” says Kirby.

In different methods, the episode highlights how far behind the U.S. has fallen within the propaganda wars. Since 2016, Moscow has expanded and refined its efforts to manage the “data surroundings” by automated propaganda. In late 2022, Russia’s “Foremost Scientific Analysis Computing Middle” was enhancing its community of tons of of hundreds of social media bots to the purpose that they had been detected on X, YouTube and TikTok lower than 1% of the time, in accordance with a top-secret doc leaked by Teixeira.

To listen to America’s data warriors inform it, the hazard is barely rising. Autocracies like Iran, North Korea, and China have gotten within the sport. China’s chief, Xi Jinping, has referred to as for expanded use of expertise in controlling worldwide public opinion, and the Chinese language army has researched using generative AI and huge language fashions to automate propaganda at scale, in accordance with a Rand research launched in September. The consequence, write the researchers, could also be “a large bot community that appears and acts human.”

Learn Extra: Tech Companies Are Taking Action on AI Election Misinformation. Will It Matter?

Nobody is aware of how efficient this AI-enhanced propaganda could also be. “I don’t assume it’s altering lots of people’s minds, it’s simply reinforcing what folks already assume,” says James Steinberg, former Deputy Nationwide Safety Adviser and dean of the Johns Hopkins Faculty of Superior Worldwide Research. Others are extra alarmed. “As AI’s function in defining and shaping the ‘data house’ grows,” wrote former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, former Nationwide Safety Adviser Henry Kissinger, and MIT dean Daniel Huttenlocher in a latest e book, “the prospects free of charge society, even free will, could also be altered.”

For college students of presidency intelligence abuse, the true hazard is in overreacting. Whereas Sullivan, Burns, and Haines tout the ability of declassification within the combat in opposition to autocratic disinformation, others fear a couple of coordinated secret-exploiting operation on the White Home. “We don’t need to chill declassification,” says Mark Zaid, a lawyer who focuses on national-security instances, “however the politicization or weaponization of intelligence is worse than at any level in our lifetime.”

Historical past helps such issues. Within the Chilly Battle, the U.S. used declassified intelligence to mislead adversaries and People alike, together with when officers asserted that Russian forces knew they had been capturing at a civilian plane after they downed Korean Air Strains Flight 007 in 1983. Within the early 2000s, the U.S. declassified what turned out to be bogus intelligence about Saddam Hussein’s weapons-of-mass-destruction program to justify the invasion of Iraq. Most not too long ago, U.S. counter-intelligence operatives on the FBI gave credence to an unreliable file collected on Trump, then briefed him on it, paving the best way for its publication.

Trump has his personal concepts in regards to the makes use of of declassification. He began his time period by allegedly revealing secrets and techniques—reportedly collected by Israeli intelligence companies—to 2 Russian officers, for causes that by no means turned clear. In 2019, he tweeted high-resolution images, reportedly taken by a multibillion-dollar KH-11 spy satellite tv for pc, displaying a broken Iranian missile website. Accused of taking secrets and techniques to his Mar-a-Lago resort in Florida, Trump falsely claimed he might declassify paperwork simply by thinking them unsecret.

What has gotten each Trump and Biden in probably the most hassle, nevertheless, isn’t misuse of declassification, however failing to safeguard the secrets and techniques to which they’ve entry. Particular counsel Robert Hur concluded Biden willfully took secret papers to his house in Wilmington and to workplaces elsewhere in Delaware and in Pennsylvania. Hur declined to convey fees. The FBI discovered secret paperwork strewn round Mar-a-Lago, and particular counsel Jack Smith has charged Trump with blocking authorities makes an attempt to get them again.

Consultants say such breaches are as a lot a product of America’s industrial creation of secrets and techniques as they’re carelessness in dealing with them. Nobody is aware of what number of secrets and techniques America creates a 12 months: the quantity grew from greater than 5 million in 2006 to greater than 95 million in 2012, and ultimately the federal government simply stopped counting. Former Protection Division officers estimate that wherever from 50% to 90% of them shouldn’t be categorized in any respect. The cheapening of American secrets and techniques has grown so excessive that the organizers of a preferred on-line online game, Battle Thunder, which crowd-sources eventualities between real-world militaries, have repeatedly warned individuals to cease making an attempt to make the sport extra correct by sharing categorized particulars in regards to the weapons programs it options.

Might the White Home’s willingness to declassify intelligence for strategic functions assist with overclassification? Advocates say it’s tougher for companies to justify maintaining secrets and techniques from the Nineteen Fifties when at this time’s spies are being extra versatile with theirs. In concept, AI could possibly be used to check the billions of presidency secrets and techniques with what’s publicly obtainable. The Public Intelligence Declassification Board, an workplace of the Nationwide Archives tasked with combating overclassification, argued for utilizing new tech in a 2020 report, and Haines has endorsed a few of its concepts.

Learn Extra: How Data Literacy Can Keep America Safe

There’ll at all times be secrets and techniques of such nice worth or delicate provenance that they should be protected. “Whereas the quantity of publicly obtainable data has basically exploded, that doesn’t imply the age of massive secrets and techniques is over,” Haines tells TIME. However mass assortment and social media have modified the financial system of secrecy. As soon as, categorized intelligence that gave decision-makers a bonus over their opponents was so laborious to return by that it was genuinely valuable for nationwide safety. Now, intelligence that when took months to gather and course of could make it all over the world in minutes. “Open supply” teams like Bellingcat have proven the worth of posting information on-line to contradict an autocrat’s false narrative earlier than it will possibly take root. To extract worth from at the least a few of its billions of secrets and techniques, argue proponents of declassification, the U.S. authorities must make them public.

That may additionally assist with what has change into a disaster of public belief within the intelligence group. In a 2019 report, Justice Division Inspector Normal Michael Horowitz discovered the FBI abused the method of making use of for warrants to spy on People 17 instances because it went after former Trump marketing campaign official Carter Web page. As not too long ago as 2021, the FBI carried out greater than 3 million searches on data collected on People, together with these concerned within the Jan. 6 riot and Black Lives Matter protests, with out warrants, in accordance with an ODNI report. It’s maybe not shocking that some People give credence to conspiracy theories, from Trump’s fulminations a couple of sinister “deep state” to presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s claims that the CIA killed his uncle.

Learn Extra: How Housewives Played a Critical Role in the CIA

Sullivan believes that accountable declassification can assist reverse this disaster of belief. “With the ability to look the American folks within the eye and say, ‘We’re monitoring this risk, we’re taking it significantly, we’re doing one thing about it,’” he says, “creates belief with a way that one’s authorities is on high of the issue.” Some intelligence specialists suggest doing extra to make sure transparency and oversight, like empowering bipartisan committees on Capitol Hill, enacting harder protections for whistle-blowers, and imposing guidelines at ODNI and Government Orders from the White Home on what will get declassified and the way it’s downgraded.

However finally, the broad authority to declassify secrets and techniques rests with the President. Which implies the Commander in Chief’s credibility is central to any try to make use of secret-sharing as a device to combat disinformation and rebuild public belief. “What units us aside is the best way we do it, and what we’re doing it for,” says the NSC’s Bitar. Or, because the CBS Information correspondent turned authorities broadcaster Edward R. Murrow instructed Congress in 1963: “Truth is one of the best propaganda.”

—With reporting by Leslie Dickstein and Simmone Shah/New York and Lissa August/Washington